We've got a pretty special Tavern Watch episode for you today, folks. It's no secret that those of us who've gotten our hands on the D&D: World of Warcraft book have been pretty excited about it, our enthusiasm even slipping out of Tavern Watch and ending up on otherwise-unrelated episodes of the Blizzard Watch Podcast. Far from a cash grab or a clumsy adaptation, this new book is a real labor of love targeted directly at that crossover audience between WoW and D&D.
Therefore, we are thrilled to be able to bring you an interview with James Wyatt from Wizards of the Coast, the lead game designer on D&D: World of Warcraft! James has been designing D&D and other RPG content since the 90s, starting with material for TSR's Masque of the Red Death D&D setting but contributing to a lot of areas of the game since then; he also did a stint on the Magic: the Gathering team, including writing the "Plane Shift" series of free products that adapted MtG elements for D&D, which later led to the stellar 5th Edition books for Ravnica, Theros, and Strixhaven. He also let us know that he's been playing WoW since launch!
James joined Liz, Joe, and Phil to talk about all kinds of aspects of adapting WoW to the tabletop, including things like how certain classes were adapted, the importance of bringing te video game to the tabletop without limiting player choice or imagination, how feedback from playtesters at Blizzard shaped the book, and even specific systems that surprised us with their thoughtful implementations (like professions, Renown, and minipets!). We could not, however, wrangle an exact date for playable Murlocs out of him -- but the dream isn't dead, as you'll hear.
Music from this episode is “Midnight Tale” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Subscribe to Tavern Watch in your podcast player of choice to keep up with the latest tabletop news!
RSS: https://feeds.acast.com/public/shows/674cf5861c6967d814005868
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3qIQaOPskXoKmqqOqNYz1k
Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/tavern-watch-podcast/id1788120623
Visit us at https://blizzardwatch.com for the latest news on Blizzard games, and don't forget to subscribe on Patreon to support our efforts! https://www.patreon.com/blizzardwatch
Discord: https://discord.gg/MY9p4d7t8U
Bluesky: @blizzardwatch.com
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:03
[music]
0:09
[music]
0:16
[music]
0:22
[music]
0:29
>> Well met, traveler.
0:31
Welcome to the tavern.
0:33
Did you know that this magical place is
0:35
where more than half of history's
0:37
greatest adventures have begun?
0:40
Before those adventurers took their
0:42
first steps, they watched and calculated
0:44
who would join their party.
0:47
See that barbarian over there?
0:49
He hails from the frozen lands.
0:51
Strong, mighty, and full of wisdom.
0:54
I've closed many a nights with that one.
0:57
They call themselves Matt Rossi.
1:00
To the right over there, that woman
1:02
working on her tinkers and mechanical
1:04
devices,
1:05
an artificer of great skill.
1:08
She is cunning and quick, and I've seen
1:10
her bounce a fair share of
1:11
ne'er-do-wells out of here before I
1:12
could even step out from behind the bar.
1:15
She's known as Liz Harper.
1:18
And that gentleman by the hearth with a
1:20
pile of tomes,
1:21
rumor has it that he is a powerful
1:23
wizard full of arcane secrets.
1:26
But around here, most just call him the
1:27
Professor.
1:29
Me, I know them to be Phil Olrich.
1:32
Oh, me, I'm Joe Perez.
1:35
I'll be your tavern keeper.
1:38
Welcome to Tavern Watch.
1:40
Hello everyone and welcome to a special
1:42
edition of Tavern Watch.
1:44
Uh, you probably [snorts] know me.
1:46
Hopefully you've listened to this
1:47
podcast enough that if you're new here,
1:48
well, welcome. And if you don't know who
1:50
I am by now, really?
1:52
Um, so I'm Joe Perez. I'm your humble
1:54
tavern keeper. Uh, joining me as always
1:56
are my wonderful co-host Phil Olrich.
1:58
How you doing, Phil?
1:59
>> Doing
2:00
>> Uh and the person who tries the rein in,
2:02
our editor in chief, uh
2:04
Liz Harper, how are you doing, Liz?
2:07
>> Hello. I'm really excited about what
2:09
we're doing today.
2:11
>> That's right. And we have a very special
2:12
guest joining us today, James Wyatt from
2:16
Wizards of the Coast, who I made a
2:19
promise that I was going to try not to
2:21
completely fanboy over today.
2:23
Um
2:24
thank you very much for joining us,
2:25
James. For those that don't necessarily
2:28
know who you are, because we have a lot
2:29
of people are coming in from other
2:30
systems,
2:32
uh who are you? What do you do?
2:34
>> Um I'm James Wyatt. I'm a principal game
2:36
designer on the Dungeons and Dragons
2:37
team at Wizards of the Coast, and I've
2:40
I've been
2:41
working there for almost 27 years, so
2:44
I've done a ton of D&D stuff. I spent a
2:47
brief time on the Magic the Gathering
2:49
team as well,
2:50
um
2:51
where I sort of pioneered crossing over
2:53
between Magic and D&D for the first time
2:55
in 20 years, and
2:58
and I've been playing World of Warcraft
2:59
almost since launch, so this [laughter]
3:02
this book we're talking about is a dream
3:04
project for me.
3:05
>> Wonderful. And I think that leads us
3:07
into the first thing I wanted to ask,
3:08
which is everything you do seems like
3:11
it's a labor of love, from like the Mask
3:13
of Red Death setting all the way through
3:14
your work through the plane shift which
3:15
you just mentioned,
3:17
um bringing magic to D&D, which was a
3:19
huge thing for me and my friends, which
3:21
I really which laid the foundations for
3:23
what came later with Theros, Ravnica,
3:26
and Strahd Haven, which are three of the
3:27
best books I think that have ever been
3:29
produced as far as like trying new
3:31
things and adding new narrative to the
3:33
game. Um and now with WoW, what what
3:37
draws you to these types of projects?
3:39
Like what what really like is that
3:41
lightning rod for you?
3:42
>> I'm a huge nerd. [laughter]
3:46
Is there a better answer than that?
3:49
>> Yeah.
3:50
>> Um I mean so
3:52
so broadly, I mean I really just enjoy
3:55
World of Warcraft, and I've always loved
3:57
the world, and and so pretty much from
3:59
the time I started playing WoW, I was
4:01
looking for ways to play D&D in that
4:04
world and explore the world in a new way
4:06
and tabletop.
4:07
So
4:08
I've I've dabbled with
4:10
with this
4:11
as a fan for years, but
4:15
thinking [clears throat] about like
4:16
I love my job. [laughter]
4:20
I I love writing D&D books that are just
4:22
full of toys that
4:24
players and DMs can use at their table.
4:26
And a book like this is a is a great
4:29
opportunity for that.
4:31
And and the other books you mentioned
4:33
are too. Like
4:34
like Ravnica was a chance to take the
4:36
renowned system that we had in the
4:37
Dungeon Master's Guide and blow that out
4:39
into a whole thing about guilds and
4:40
factions and how those interact with
4:42
each other and how you can
4:44
advance in a faction while you're
4:45
continuing to go about your adventure
4:47
and career and how different factions
4:48
interact with each other. And we built
4:50
on that in the World of Warcraft book.
4:52
Theros was was like the same thing but
4:54
with what if we do that with piety
4:56
instead and what does devotion to a god
4:57
look like and just just toys to play
5:00
with. [laughter] So
5:03
>> Uh I think
5:04
>> monsters, lots of monsters.
5:06
>> Uh I've been blown I've been blown away
5:08
with the the quality of content in it.
5:10
Not just saying that as a a fan of your
5:12
work, but just like from a book
5:14
perspective, I think it's it's just it's
5:17
a piece of art really.
5:19
Did you find balancing all of the the
5:22
sort of like weird aspects of not just
5:24
D&D but World of Warcraft difficult?
5:27
I mean lore, game mechanics, and tone.
5:31
Basically, did you find it hard to be
5:33
true to both D&D and wow? What were some
5:35
of the more challenging aspects of that?
5:38
>> I did not find it hard to be true to
5:40
both.
5:41
Although hm I I guess because I saw my
5:45
path very clearly and and again thinking
5:47
about the magic books like when I was
5:49
writing the plane shift articles, I was
5:50
would sometimes dabble in what if we
5:53
adapt mechanics from the magic trading
5:56
card game into D&D in some way ranging
5:58
from like what if we let you base your
6:00
personality traits on color identity
6:02
instead of on alignment.
6:04
At one point I was I don't think I ever
6:06
put this in a in an article, but I was
6:07
playing around with like a a spell point
6:10
system that used colored mana as a as a
6:12
mechanic.
6:14
And ultimately we never put any of that
6:16
into the books because the goal of the
6:18
books was to play D&D in these worlds
6:20
that happened to have been created for
6:22
Magic the Gathering. And so so that um
6:25
was sort of the defining principle for
6:28
going into this book as well. The goal
6:29
is not to translate World of Warcraft
6:31
mechanics into D&D. It's to let you play
6:34
D&D in the world of Warcraft. Um, now
6:37
that said, there are the way that
6:39
classes function and the way that
6:41
species function um
6:44
that that has mechanical implications in
6:46
World of Warcraft that we can translate
6:48
or paraphrase or adapt into D&D
6:51
mechanics in a way that um that evokes
6:53
the same feeling when you're playing in
6:55
the tabletop game. So that was sometimes
6:58
a challenge, but like
7:01
we're not setting out to to say, okay,
7:03
we're bringing a talent point system
7:05
into D&D and and doing that kind of
7:09
fiddly math of percentages that World of
7:11
Warcraft can do because it's a computer
7:13
game and translating that into D&D. None
7:15
of that. Just what does it feel like to
7:17
play a Paladin in WoW? Okay, how can we
7:19
evoke
7:20
evoke that feeling um when you're
7:23
playing a Paladin in in Azeroth in D&D?
7:26
>> Uh, so what was the biggest challenge
7:28
you faced when you're trying to make
7:30
this conversion? Because there's so much
7:32
in this book that feels like a
7:35
really straight draw from World of
7:38
Warcraft, but there is there is a lot of
7:41
wiggle room, a lot of things that you
7:42
need to
7:45
mold to fit into into Dungeons &
7:48
Dragons. So was there anything that was
7:50
particularly hard?
7:52
>> So the thing I love about the classes
7:54
chapter in this book is that each class
7:56
um presented a different problem that
7:59
required a different solution.
8:01
I keep saying it's not a one size fits
8:03
all solution to
8:05
to bringing one class into bringing a
8:07
WoW class into D&D. And so some of those
8:09
solutions are
8:11
um more drastic than others uh that
8:14
presented design challenges. Like I was
8:17
talking earlier today about the Death
8:18
Knight. Like we penciled in right away,
8:20
okay, this is going to be a Paladin
8:21
subclass. And then as soon as we start
8:24
down to to sit down to start
8:25
implementing that, oh okay, that that
8:27
that's going to require some changes to
8:29
the way the basic Paladin functions. So
8:31
that's a whole new innovation in how we
8:34
design subclasses that alter the base
8:36
class that they're attached to, which is
8:39
awesome new design space for us to
8:41
explore.
8:42
Um
8:43
and then I I keep saying I I think the
8:45
Shaman is probably the thing that's
8:47
going to raise the most eyebrows in our
8:49
implementation
8:51
[laughter]
8:52
because the Barbarian isn't the first
8:53
thing that's going to pop into your
8:54
head. But thinking about the Shaman as
8:57
the Horde's answer to Paladins
8:59
originally
9:00
and um
9:02
and looking at the Barbarian subclasses
9:04
we're pointing you to, both the Path of
9:06
the Wild uh the World Tree in the
9:09
Player's Handbook and the two new ones
9:11
in this book, those are super magicky
9:13
subclasses. And so the Shaman I'm
9:16
playing right now, I'm throwing
9:18
lightning and lava and cold at at my
9:20
enemies as I swing my uh Flame Tongue
9:23
Warhammer and
9:24
I feel like a Shaman. [laughter] It's
9:26
it's pretty awesome. So
9:28
>> Yeah, it feels very enhancement Shaman
9:30
coded.
9:31
>> Yes.
9:32
Yes, which is my my spec for sure.
9:35
So
9:36
[laughter]
9:37
so
9:37
>> knew I liked this guy.
9:42
>> Well, hilariously in WoW my main is a
9:43
Warrior.
9:45
>> So yeah, I knew I liked this guy.
9:46
>> [laughter]
9:49
>> And there's another interesting one size
9:51
does not fit all thing. Like at one
9:52
point we were I I was ready to say if
9:54
you want to play a Fury spec Warrior, go
9:56
ahead and make a Barbarian with the
9:58
Berserker subclass.
10:00
And there was some concern that that
10:03
that option ended up in the sidebar.
10:05
There was some concern with the idea of
10:06
saying
10:08
this class in D&D
10:10
or or this class in WoW, rather, maps to
10:12
two different classes in D&D, that that
10:14
would just cause confusion, which I
10:15
think is is accurate.
10:17
Um, the Holy Paladin might have been a
10:19
War Cleric, and again, that ended up as
10:20
a sidebar option,
10:22
um, but we gave you a a Holy subclass as
10:25
well. Lots of challenges, lots of uh
10:29
design fun.
10:30
>> Honestly, the book the book is great. It
10:32
feels so Warcraft. I I love it. I can't
10:35
overstate that.
10:36
>> Thank you.
10:38
>> Yeah, which does kind of bring us to
10:39
another one. Um, so one of the one of
10:41
the I'd say major differences between
10:42
WoW and, let's say, modern D&D, WoW kind
10:45
of has this concept of the Holy Trinity
10:47
they call it, the the tank, healer, DPS
10:49
and gameplay. Everyone has kind of the
10:50
strictly delineated role.
10:52
>> Yeah.
10:53
>> Um, especially once you get into group
10:54
content. Um, D&D doesn't in the past,
10:58
I'd say D&D has had that kind of
10:59
mechanic, more so in fourth edition, not
11:01
so much in fifth, and so you see a lot
11:04
of content about character building in
11:06
fifth edition, and it's about optimizing
11:08
for damage, optimizing for damage
11:09
output.
11:10
Um, how do you kind of
11:12
bring that sense of like the roles that
11:15
the WoW specs play into something like
11:19
into like the dungeon
11:20
>> That's a great question. So
11:22
one of the
11:23
the things we realized early on as an
11:26
issue
11:27
that that was just kind of stand as a
11:29
difference between the two games is when
11:31
you you choose your class and spec in
11:33
WoW, you're you're as you said, slotting
11:35
yourself very narrowly into a a defined
11:37
role. So when you're a Holy Paladin, you
11:40
are a healer, you're not a tank anymore,
11:43
you're a healer.
11:44
Um, when you're playing a Paladin in
11:46
D&D, regardless of the choices that you
11:48
make, you are a healer and a tank, and
11:50
you're dealing a lot of damage.
11:53
Um, and so the the feat choices and the
11:56
subclass class choices that we recommend
11:58
for modeling each spec can steer you a
12:02
little deeper into one aspect of that
12:04
broad role, but they're not going to
12:06
close off the other options to you. So
12:08
when you choose the Holy the oath of the
12:10
Holy Paladin subclass,
12:12
you're uh
12:13
healer, tank, damage dealer
12:16
with a specialty in healing. Um that's
12:19
one of the reasons why I talk about
12:20
evoking the feeling of playing these
12:22
characters in WoW rather than
12:24
translating directly because that is a
12:27
fundamental difference between the
12:28
games. And that's because um
12:30
you know we don't have a looking for
12:32
group mechanic in in D&D where you can
12:34
say okay
12:36
I need
12:37
we have to have a tank and two DPS and a
12:40
healer for this party. Um there is
12:43
tremendous flexibility in how you build
12:45
a party in D&D and um we wanted to
12:48
preserve that for so that everybody
12:50
sitting at the table can play the
12:51
character that they want to play and
12:52
invest in that character long term. Um
12:55
that that's how
12:56
the D&D works and and you can make a
12:58
drastically unbalanced party and that's
13:00
also fine and uh you will have your own
13:02
unique challenges but the game is not
13:04
going to prevent you from doing that.
13:06
>> Mhm. Uh I'm sure you're familiar with
13:09
the the concept of an opinionated game.
13:11
Um uh so it it in for those at home it's
13:14
the the it's the idea that a game knows
13:16
what it's trying to be and leans hard
13:18
in. Um do you think that what you've
13:21
crafted here leans in that direction
13:24
more than the base fifth edition which
13:26
feels like it's largely meant to appeal
13:29
to the the broadest audience it can for
13:32
uh tabletop um or do you feel that it is
13:35
another tool in the quiver of that?
13:37
>> I definitely think of it as an as a
13:39
whole set of toys for your toy box um
13:41
that
13:42
that you can do with it whatever you
13:44
want. Like um
13:46
we provide a lot of adventure content in
13:48
the form of the dungeons in this book
13:49
but it's not a campaign that you play
13:52
through. It's dungeon tools that you can
13:54
add to your your toy box as a DM. Um so
13:58
and like part of that is that we're
14:01
aiming at this book is squarely aimed at
14:03
the broad overlap between WoW fans and
14:05
D&D fans.
14:06
Um I think there's it has a lot to offer
14:09
D&D fans who have not played WoW or WoW
14:11
fans who have not played D&D although
14:13
it's not it's not designed as an
14:15
product to D&D. But um to appeal to that
14:19
that overlap audience,
14:22
what that audience likes is to toys to
14:24
play with [laughter] um and and options
14:26
and um
14:28
ideas and inspiration that they can add
14:30
into their campaigns um which is what
14:33
this book is hopefully full of.
14:35
So, um like even with with Chromie
14:38
giving you your own timeline to play
14:40
with in the introduction to the book the
14:41
the whole point of that is
14:44
play in the Azeroth that you want to
14:46
play in, build the campaign that you
14:47
want to run run and and that your
14:50
characters want to explore and um
14:53
go wild with it. That that's what the
14:55
tabletop game is all about for me.
14:57
>> And that's that's the big
14:58
differentiation between playing a video
15:01
game where everything's fixed and
15:02
playing Dungeons & Dragons where you can
15:04
do any crazy thing. Um
15:06
I'm wondering
15:07
>> ran a playtest Oh, sorry. Go ahead.
15:09
>> No.
15:09
>> Uh well, I was I was wondering there's
15:12
so much in this book. What what's the
15:14
best thing that you would say to steal
15:16
from this book for your other
15:18
non-Warcraft games?
15:20
>> I would start with the monsters.
15:22
[laughter] Um I mean I I've
15:23
>> Yeah.
15:24
>> I've used Nagas in my D&D games a lot.
15:27
[laughter]
15:28
Um my my daughter and her girlfriend are
15:30
really excited about bringing the
15:31
profession system into their core D&D
15:34
games which which is interesting to me
15:35
because it's a really light system and
15:37
not not huge impact. Um but I said in an
15:42
interview yesterday and my daughter
15:43
responded saying, yes, this is exactly
15:45
it. It's a democratization of the
15:47
crafting rules that are in the Dungeon
15:48
Master's Guide making them open to
15:50
everybody and that that's what excites
15:52
them about it. So, um but
15:56
with your DMs go ahead there's species
15:59
and character class options that are fun
16:02
and exciting. Like
16:03
I sat down to to make a character for
16:05
the campaign I'm playing in now make
16:06
make making my Shaman character. My
16:08
Shaman was like the third character I
16:09
made because there were so many options
16:10
I wanted to try out. [laughter]
16:12
Um and I finally settled on Orc Shaman.
16:15
I think I'm happy with that choice, but
16:16
I still wonder my demon hunter would
16:18
have been like.
16:20
>> The options, that's always the hard
16:22
part.
16:23
>> Yeah. Yeah. But um to your earlier point
16:26
just a second ago Liz,
16:27
when we were doing play testing for
16:29
this,
16:30
uh we went down to Blizzard headquarters
16:32
and had
16:33
Blizzard employees come and play test
16:35
and that included people who had never
16:37
heard of D&D or never played it before.
16:39
And I love playing with new people
16:40
because they don't know what they're
16:41
supposed to do.
16:43
So they will do whatever and I
16:45
I laid the groundwork for that saying
16:48
this is a tabletop role playing game.
16:49
You're limited only by your imagination.
16:51
You can talk to anybody you meet. You
16:53
can interact with anybody you can see.
16:55
Like we were running the beginning of
16:56
Shadow of Hand Keep and we had to adapt
16:58
the beginning of that adventure because
17:00
you go in and there's this portcullis
17:02
that you can see through into the
17:03
courtyard and
17:04
in D&D, well you could just shoot start
17:07
shooting magic missiles through the
17:08
portcullis and picking off monsters or
17:10
shooting your bow. Can't do that
17:11
anymore. It it just sort of arbitrarily
17:13
puts a barrier there.
17:16
There aren't so many arbitrary barriers
17:18
in a tabletop game.
17:20
>> Uh so you mentioned professions and uh
17:23
like your daughter being very excited
17:24
about it. Um the concept of professions,
17:27
gathering, crafting, uh that is
17:29
something that is I think very core to
17:31
World of Warcraft. Uh and players may be
17:34
familiar with it from that game. Uh but
17:36
it feels almost like it returns an
17:38
aspect of D&D that used to be prominent
17:41
uh in prior editions, but kind of went
17:43
away in like fourth and fifth. Like I
17:45
remember it being very
17:46
uh key in like third edition. Uh was a
17:49
huge thing in third and 3.5. Uh was the
17:52
development of the system
17:53
>> craft skill and a profession skill.
17:55
>> Yeah, exactly.
17:56
Um was the development of the system
17:58
simply a way to acknowledge that aspect
18:00
of World of Warcraft or was it also
18:01
developed with the hindsight of how this
18:03
used to be an aspect of D&D?
18:05
>> Um a little of both. So it's something
18:08
that D&D players ask about a lot. And um
18:11
I I will always have some measure of
18:13
resistance like
18:15
this is not a game about simulating an
18:16
economy or how you can run a business or
18:20
how can make more money adventuring more
18:23
money doing blacksmithing then you could
18:25
as an adventurer. If that's true then
18:27
then the system is flawed.
18:29
Um but it is an important an important
18:32
part of a character's identity in WoW
18:34
and
18:35
and so what we built was
18:37
uh
18:38
a pretty thin layer that adds on to
18:40
what's already in D&D which as you point
18:43
out is not nearly as prominent as it was
18:44
in third edition.
18:46
Um
18:47
I think
18:48
adding the foraging the the
18:50
the gathering professions on top of the
18:53
existing foraging rules for overland
18:54
journeys in the Dungeon Master's Guide
18:56
um
18:57
again just sort of broadens the appeal
18:59
of that. You don't have to just forage
19:00
for food. You can look for herbs or or
19:02
or or you can skin animals or whatever.
19:05
Um and that's that's fun and interesting
19:07
and again I don't think you're ever
19:09
going to make as much money
19:10
gathering things as you will going into
19:13
dungeons and finding treasure.
19:15
Um and then the
19:17
the profession as I said is
19:19
democratization. You don't have to have
19:21
the Arcana skill. You can just be a
19:22
really good blacksmith and make powerful
19:24
magic armor um and and anybody can do
19:27
that and and
19:29
it's not an activity that that's going
19:31
to replace your adventuring but
19:33
something that you can do in between
19:34
adventures or with your bastion.
19:37
>> Uh so speaking of adventures let's
19:39
uh let's talk about another aspect of
19:41
WoW that everybody's pretty familiar
19:42
with uh that I thought was interesting
19:44
the way it was converted over dungeons
19:46
and raids.
19:47
>> Mhm.
19:48
>> it seems like a pretty straightforward
19:50
conversion when you think about it. WoW
19:51
has dungeons. D&D has dungeons. Seems
19:53
pretty straightforward but
19:55
um the Shadow Fang Keep thing is a good
19:58
uh good thing to bring up. A lot of WoW
20:00
dungeons seem to be art well not seem to
20:02
be they are pretty linear because the
20:04
goal in a WoW dungeon is to get you in
20:06
take you on a straight line through
20:08
bosses and you know get loot and get
20:09
out.
20:10
Um
20:11
>> Rinse repeat.
20:12
>> yeah rinse and repeat exactly. Um but
20:16
you know in D&D players obviously like
20:18
you said they expect to be only limited
20:19
by their imagination. They're doing
20:21
anything that they can think of. Um
20:23
maybe they more tactics just going
20:24
straight in and murdering everything.
20:26
Um was there any consideration giving to
20:29
adding more options with the dungeons
20:31
that did get brought over to the book
20:32
like adding you know adding some
20:34
additional twists and turns or
20:36
you know adding like if the party just
20:38
decides to sneak through here's what
20:39
they here's what happens etc.
20:40
>> Yeah.
20:41
Yeah and we did do some of that. Uh
20:43
there's an an odd in the dead mines to
20:46
sneaking through and posing as a as a
20:48
pirate and interacting with the
20:51
the Defiance Brotherhood that way.
20:53
There's some notes in the Dire Maul
20:55
dungeon about uh
20:57
challenging King Gordok and and taking
20:59
that role.
21:00
Um and our our general approach to the
21:04
dungeons was a pretty light touch so
21:06
that like like we give you a map, we put
21:09
pins on the map saying here's the bosses
21:10
we know you're going to fight.
21:12
But what happens in between those is a
21:14
lot more flexible. Um
21:16
we we give the DM tools to put together
21:19
encounters that you might have along the
21:20
way but it's not there's no expectation
21:22
that you're just going to grind your way
21:24
through mob after mob after mob to get
21:26
till you get to the next boss.
21:28
Um the Ice Crown Citadel adventure that
21:30
we did for D&D Beyond is is a pretty
21:33
direct conversion and it is pretty
21:35
linear and I I kind of wish that weren't
21:37
true.
21:38
Um but there's still opportunity like
21:41
there were some quests that aren't in
21:43
the game anymore but that I think
21:45
appeared when when the game when when
21:48
the dungeon was new, the raid was new,
21:49
there were requests to like go in and
21:51
retrieve this member of
21:52
of the Ashman Verdict who was sent as a
21:54
spy and has been captured by Lady Death
21:57
Whisper. So I I I kept those in to give
22:00
some added element of we're not just
22:03
fighting the boss, we're we're taking
22:05
back this person who's potentially been
22:07
indoctrinated into the cult or we're
22:08
rescuing this person that Blood Queen
22:10
Lana'thel is holding captive. So that
22:12
there's at least some element of
22:14
exploration and interaction that you can
22:16
do there.
22:17
Um but but with most of the dungeons in
22:19
the book that is like I was starting to
22:21
got off track but I was starting to say
22:23
we put the pins in the map and then what
22:24
happens in between the pins, that's
22:26
where the magic happens. That's in any
22:28
D&D adventure, that's where the players
22:29
do things that are completely
22:31
unexpected, and we we give the DM a lot
22:33
of latitude to figure out how that's
22:35
going to go. Um it's it's a much lighter
22:38
presentation of dungeon of adventure
22:39
content than we usually do. It's almost
22:42
more comparable to the half-page
22:43
adventures in the Dungeon Master's Guide
22:44
than just something fleshed out like a
22:46
Dragon Delves or a a book-length
22:48
adventure. So hopefully that light touch
22:51
creates space for um the chaos and
22:54
craziness to happen that makes D&D so
22:56
awesome.
22:57
>> Um Renown was one of the systems I was
22:59
really interested in seeing in this book
23:01
because that's we're so used to it as
23:04
World of Warcraft players, but this is
23:06
really giving mechanics for something
23:09
that D&D players tend to leave as just
23:11
kind of a light bit of role playing in
23:14
between adventures. Um how did where did
23:17
this come from? I mean obviously it's a
23:19
big part of World of Warcraft, but
23:22
how did you go about, you know, making
23:24
mechanics for Renown and uh fleshing
23:27
that out for D&D?
23:28
>> Yeah, so the the Renown mechanics
23:31
existed already. They were in the 2014
23:33
DMG, and we brought them forward into
23:35
the 2024 DMG. I talked about how we used
23:37
them in Ravnica to build them out, and
23:39
and basically we took the same approach
23:40
in this book that we did in Ravnica. Um
23:43
it it's pretty different than Reputation
23:45
in WoW because of the pace at which you
23:47
get it.
23:48
Um and you know, it's a smaller scale of
23:52
about 50 points, I guess. Um where the
23:55
expectation is that over time well
23:58
the beauty of it of it is it's a really
24:00
flexible system.
24:01
>> Mhm.
24:01
>> general expectation is that over the
24:03
course of 20 levels you might get your
24:05
Renown up to up to 50 with a faction and
24:07
get the the top tier rewards for that.
24:10
And it it's not a matter of grinding of
24:13
doing daily quests over and over again.
24:16
It's
24:17
sort of expected gradual progression.
24:19
But the flexibility of it is that like
24:22
in Icecrown Citadel, we gave you also an
24:24
Ashen Verdict Renown uh track that goes
24:27
up much faster. If you start the
24:29
adventure at level 16, then by the time
24:31
you're level 20, you'll have 50 points
24:32
of renown and you'll have the the top
24:34
tier
24:35
renown rewards from from the Ashen
24:37
Verdict. So
24:40
where in WoW you're you're doing
24:41
Icecrown Citadel over and over again to
24:43
grind that number up,
24:45
here you're doing it once and hopefully
24:47
getting the the
24:49
top rings and best rewards by the end.
24:53
So like it comes down to the the
24:56
the fundamental mechanical differences
24:58
between the games that
25:00
of what what gameplay looks like that
25:03
D&D is not a game about grinding
25:04
usually.
25:05
[laughter]
25:06
It's not a game we expect you to
25:08
where we expect you to repeat
25:11
quests or adventures or dungeons or
25:13
anything
25:14
because we expect players expect the
25:16
world to change based on what they do.
25:19
And
25:20
all that stuff that I outlined at the
25:22
start of the Adventures chapter in the
25:23
book of here's some things to watch out
25:26
for when you're porting quests over from
25:27
WoW to D&D. The games are different in
25:30
some important ways. There's lots of
25:31
inspiration to be had, but
25:34
bear those differences in mind.
25:35
>> So I got to say there was a lot of stuff
25:37
that when I saw it in here I was like,
25:38
yeah, this makes sense in D&D like the
25:40
way that a lot of the classes were
25:41
adapted to the species or like finding
25:43
the renown system.
25:44
The one that blew me away when I saw it
25:46
that it that has an adaptation and you
25:48
may know where I'm already going
25:50
>> Oh, I'm curious to see where you're
25:51
going.
25:51
>> is companion pets, mini pets. Like the
25:54
system for having a little buddy that
25:56
like you take care of them and maybe
25:57
they give you a little mechanical
25:58
benefit.
26:01
So obviously my the question that leads
26:03
from that is what is your favorite
26:05
battle pet in World of Warcraft?
26:07
>> [laughter]
26:08
>> I have not gotten into the battle pet
26:10
system in WoW at all,
26:12
which is is kind of sad, but
26:15
I have a special place in my heart for
26:18
the little Pky Grief. In Icecrown
26:21
Citadel, the first boss is Lord Bone
26:24
Marrow.
26:24
>> Lord Marrowgar.
26:25
>> Yeah, Lord Marrowgar.
26:26
>> The little guy there yeah, the little
26:28
guy [laughter] spins around and yells
26:29
Bone Storm. Yeah.
26:30
>> So I I put that
26:31
>> pet as an like the book is a
26:34
again a very light treatment of how
26:35
companion pets work, um with the one
26:38
real example being in the Ice wind Dale
26:40
adventure you can get that little mini
26:43
marragar pet that runs around and
26:44
SCREAMS BONE STORM.
26:46
>> [laughter]
26:49
>> THAT'S IT. THAT'S THE SOUND BITE FOR THE
26:50
PROMO.
26:51
>> That's perfect. [laughter]
26:52
Yep.
26:53
Socials are sorted.
26:55
Cool.
26:57
>> Um
26:57
>> So uh
26:59
and giving them some mechanical impact
27:01
was actually uh
27:02
a note that came back from Blizzard as
27:04
in the course of of working on this that
27:08
like we just introduced in Arcana
27:10
Unleashed um spells that let you make
27:13
your familiar more like a a battling
27:17
companion.
27:18
Um
27:19
so that's not the direction we wanted to
27:21
take these,
27:22
but we wanted them to have some impact
27:24
and so that's this is where we ended up
27:26
is this
27:27
again building off a a minor system in
27:29
the Dungeon Master's Guide of Loyalty uh
27:32
and blowing that out a little bit to
27:34
give mechanical benefits when your pet
27:36
likes you enough.
27:37
>> Uh another thing going back to something
27:39
we talked about earlier I did want to
27:40
talk about species a little bit. Um the
27:43
list of playable species in this book is
27:45
incredible. It's very broad uh and it
27:48
includes a few that you can play as that
27:51
still aren't available in WoW itself uh
27:54
uh Tonka for example.
27:56
>> Mhm.
27:56
>> Which of these did you feel was the
27:58
easiest to get right or to like make it
28:01
feel right and which did you feel was
28:02
maybe the hardest?
28:04
>> Interesting. The the course of
28:06
development of the species was
28:07
interesting because um
28:09
our our initial intention was to make
28:12
sure that every species was not just
28:15
like like the dwarves would be different
28:17
from the Player's Handbook dwarves or
28:18
would have
28:20
of an origin feat you could take that
28:22
would
28:23
identify you as an iron iron forged
28:25
dwarf or a bronze beard dwarf or a wild
28:27
hammer dwarf or a dark iron dwarf and
28:29
and be a little mechanically different.
28:31
And we ended up abandoning that because
28:34
uh we felt like it was more important to
28:36
let you combine your species and
28:38
background in a way that could be
28:40
interesting for developing a character
28:42
rather than
28:43
if we if we
28:45
put those in feats then that has to be
28:46
your background. You have to be take the
28:49
Iron Forge dwarf background to get the
28:51
Iron Forge dwarf feet.
28:53
Um so
28:55
letting go of that I think was the the
28:57
biggest
28:58
challenge for me. Um but species like
29:02
hmm
29:04
the elves were an interesting challenge
29:05
because we had to design some new spells
29:07
to give them
29:08
[laughter] uh
29:10
which was also super fun. The Draenei
29:13
were a lot of fun. Um we yeah we started
29:16
off in a different direction
29:18
there and brought them into a a nice
29:20
place where it's like okay we got the
29:21
Draenei and the Lightforged Draenei.
29:23
It's super easy for us to add Manari
29:25
Eredar which is an aesthetic cosmetic
29:27
option in in WoW and also the Krokul
29:31
um because it's it's just one more line
29:33
on the table. Sure that's easy.
29:35
So uh that was that was something that
29:38
made me super happy.
29:40
A little bit of delight in that design.
29:42
I remember wow it's been a it's been a
29:44
long time since I was working on the
29:45
species. I remember the Forsaken proving
29:47
some
29:48
challenges.
29:49
>> Mm.
29:50
>> Uh but it's not as hard as it used to be
29:52
because now that cure spells work on
29:54
undead um
29:55
we don't have to
29:56
>> Yeah.
29:58
>> we don't have to bend over backwards to
29:59
make sure that you can survive as a
30:00
character.
30:01
>> I mean you don't want to you want to
30:02
have your players stock harm just to
30:04
just to heal your Forsaken ally?
30:07
>> heal [laughter] your party.
30:10
>> Yeah.
30:10
>> So I've
30:11
I've got an open-ended question here for
30:13
you. If you could have free reign to
30:15
pick and adapt something to a D&D book,
30:17
what would it be?
30:18
>> Something outside of WoW?
30:20
>> Anything. Like you said you're a huge
30:22
nerd.
30:23
>> Let's say something
30:24
What was that show?
30:25
>> I'm just saying James James James
30:27
probably has a a a large swath of
30:29
interest. I'm I'm curious
30:31
what he what he would pick from from
30:33
that.
30:34
>> I mean honestly I've I've been making
30:35
the joke that if I get to do a second
30:37
World of Warcraft book, I'll put off my
30:38
retirement. And I've I've said it so
30:41
many times that it's maybe not a joke
30:43
anymore. [laughter]
30:46
Um, but I like saying it because it
30:48
makes my my manager's blood pressure
30:49
rise. [laughter]
30:54
[gasps] I mean, there's a lot more that
30:55
I want to do with Azeroth. Uh,
30:58
I keep thinking about it. I mean,
30:59
talking about this book so much that
31:01
it's hard for me to let it go out into
31:02
the wild and just
31:04
fly, be free. I I want to keep
31:05
tinkering.
31:07
Um,
31:08
like one of one of our D&D Beyond team
31:11
members had a running joke every week he
31:12
would ask about playable Murlocs in the
31:14
book. [laughter] Speaking of species
31:16
that you can't play in the book.
31:17
>> funny you should mention that because
31:18
Corey, one of our our folks from the the
31:20
the site wanted me to ask you playable
31:22
Murlocs when.
31:24
>> No, [laughter] that was me. That was me.
31:28
>> So I hope to do a second book someday
31:30
that will be in there along with like
31:32
Furbolgs and Kobold and whatever other
31:34
>> Oh, man.
31:35
>> uh, people species we want to throw in.
31:39
>> Uh, I I we're running out of time, so I
31:42
I I do want to just say that I think if
31:44
you were to
31:45
have the opportunity to do a a second
31:47
book with the amount of love that I
31:49
personally have for this one, um, I
31:51
would be there with bells on uh, to
31:53
receive that and champion that in any
31:55
way shape or form. Um,
31:57
>> Thank you. Can you send a note to my
31:59
manager?
32:00
>> [laughter]
32:01
>> I I will. I will. Um,
32:04
but I do want to thank you and thank you
32:05
very much for your time and taking a a
32:08
little bit of time to talk with us about
32:09
this book and and share your love of it
32:11
with us. Um, and I do have one last
32:13
question that you are not required to
32:14
answer, but I'm going to ask it anyway.
32:17
Uh, so what's the name of your night elf
32:18
warrior that you totally did not sneak
32:20
into this book?
32:21
>> Uh, Rielta and her her she appears
32:24
writing the spirit of Ethereo uh, on the
32:27
mounts and companions
32:29
section.
32:29
>> Yep.
32:30
>> Awesome.
32:31
>> not like I did not actually submit a
32:33
picture of my character for as reference
32:35
for the artist, but I I I her.
32:38
>> Excellent.
32:40
>> Uh, well, James, thank you very much for
32:42
joining us today. We really appreciated
32:45
it. Uh, you've you've You've put a big
32:47
smile on my face with this book and a
32:49
big smile on my face just spending some
32:51
time talking with us.
32:52
Uh,
32:53
>> I'm so glad.
32:54
>> And friends at home, if you are
32:56
listening to this, you're very clearly
32:57
interested in
32:59
this book. Go pick it up, like please.
33:01
Like let's let's let's see if we can get
33:03
the the numbers up and and help get a
33:04
second book cuz that'd be great.
33:05
>> Yeah, it's so [laughter] good. Stop stop
33:07
James from retiring by by getting that
33:09
second book slated, please. I would
33:11
[laughter] love it.
33:13
>> Uh, well, thank you very much everybody
33:15
and with that we'll see [music] you next
33:17
time. Blizzard Watch is made possible
33:19
due to generous contributions at
33:21
patreon.com/blizzardwatch. [music]
33:23
Your continuous support means that our
33:25
site and community is able to thrive and
33:28
grow. Patreon supporters are able to
33:30
enjoy [music] exclusive benefits like
33:31
early access to our podcast, a better
33:34
chance at having your question answered
33:35
on our podcasts or [music] the queue and
33:37
an ads-free site experience.
33:39
With that friends, we'll see you next
33:41
time.
33:44
Dungeons and Dragons World of Warcraft
33:46
gameplay expansion book is available now
33:49
at local retailers.
33:51
Find your friendly local game store if
33:53
you're interested in a copy.
33:56
The book will run you $59.99 USD or your
34:00
regional equivalent. And again, support
34:02
local game stores.
Games

